......................................................................................
What are the Differences Between
Hydraulics and Pneumatics?
There are major
differences between hydraulic and pneumatic systems, but also a number of
similarities.
Both systems,
hydraulics and pneumatics, work as an actuator using a pump, and are controlled
by valves to convert fluid pressure to mechanical motion.
The force that is
applied at one point is transmitted to another point via an incompressible
fluid. This is usually a type of oil for hydraulics and air
for pneumatics.
Hydraulics
Hydraulics use fluids which are not
compressible and maintain their consistency.
Hydraulic
systems are used in many industries, especially by the automotive industry.
They
are also used in elevators, dams, machine tools, amusement parks, and turbines.
Hydraulics
are not used for applications such as food preparation, as
there is a risk of oil contamination.
Hydraulic systems tend to be quite
large and complex.
Hydraulics
also take up more room as they needs a reservoir to hold the fluid which will
flow through the system.
On
account of their large components, more pressure is needed is for hydraulic
systems. This also tends to make them more expensive.
As they are usually bigger,
hydraulics can take on larger and heavier loads than pneumatics as oil is not
compressible.
All
this means that hydraulics are usually slower than pneumatics as oil is viscous
and so takes more energy to move through pipes.
Pneumatics
Pneumatic systems are commonly
powered by dry or lubricated compressed air or inert gases.
Pneumatics
are mainly used in shock absorption because gas is compressible so equipment is
less susceptible to shock damage.
Pneumatics
are used in many fields including robotics, dentistry, mining and construction.
Unlike
hydraulics, pneumatics can be used in the food, pharmaceutical, and biotech
industries because systems are cleaner and there is less risk of contamination.
Pneumatic systems can be quite
simple, often just on/off switches.
This
makes pneumatics cheaper than hydraulics, plus air is cheap and easy to store
compared to oil or any other liquid. When it needs to be disposed of it can
also be expelled into the atmosphere.
Pneumatics, faster, offers rapid
movement of cylinders at smaller size due to air compressor flow rates which
flow quickly with little resistance.
Summary
Medium
- Hydraulics – liquids, oil, water or a mixture
- Pneumatics – Gas, usually air
- Hydraulics – liquids, oil, water or a mixture
- Pneumatics – Gas, usually air
Speed
- Hydraulics – Slower, more complicated larger systems
- Pneumatics – Faster, simpler and quicker
- Hydraulics – Slower, more complicated larger systems
- Pneumatics – Faster, simpler and quicker
Cost
- Hydraulics – Expensive – more complex and larger
- Pneumatics – Cheap – no reservoir needed for storage
- Hydraulics – Expensive – more complex and larger
- Pneumatics – Cheap – no reservoir needed for storage
Pressure
- Hydraulics – Utilises around 3000 to 5000 psi (up to 10000 psi)
- Pneumatics – Utilises around 100 psi (up to 150 psi)
- Hydraulics – Utilises around 3000 to 5000 psi (up to 10000 psi)
- Pneumatics – Utilises around 100 psi (up to 150 psi)
No comments:
Post a Comment