Showing posts with label Seismologists. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Seismologists. Show all posts

Saturday, June 20, 2020

EARTHQUAKE MAGNITUDES - Measuring the Big One - Earthquakes are very hard to measure on a standard scale of size. The problem is like finding one number for the quality of a baseball pitcher. You can start with the pitcher's win-loss record, but there are more things to consider: earned-run average, strikeouts and walks, career longevity and so on. Baseball statisticians tinker with indexes that weigh these factors. Earthquakes are easily as complicated as pitchers. They are fast or slow. Some are gentle, others are violent. They're even right-handed or left-handed. They are oriented different ways — horizontal, vertical, or in between. They occur in different geologic settings, deep within continents or out in the ocean. Yet somehow, we want a single meaningful number for ranking the world's earthquakes. The goal has always been to figure out the total amount of energy a quake releases, because that tells us profound things about the dynamics of the Earth's interior. The pioneering seismologist Charles Richter started in the 1930s by simplifying everything he could think of. He chose one standard instrument, a Wood-Anderson seismograph, used only nearby earthquakes in Southern California, and took only one piece of data — the distance A in millimeters that the seismograph needle moved. He worked up a simple adjustment factor B to allow for near versus distant quakes, and that was the first Richter scale of local magnitude ML.

Visible earthquake damage.
///////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
Earthquake Magnitudes
Measuring the Big One
By Andrew Alden



These days, an earthquake happens and right away it is on the news, including its magnitude.
Instant earthquake magnitudes seem as routine an achievement as reporting the temperature, but they're the fruit of generations of scientific work.
Why Earthquakes Are Hard to Measure
Earthquakes are very hard to measure on a standard scale of size.
The problem is like finding one number for the quality of a baseball pitcher.
You can start with the pitcher's win-loss record, but there are more things to consider: earned-run average, strikeouts and walks, career longevity and so on.
Baseball statisticians tinker with indexes that weigh these factors (for more, visit the About Baseball Guide).
Earthquakes are easily as complicated as pitchers. They are fast or slow.
Some are gentle, others are violent. They're even right-handed or left-handed.
They are oriented different ways — horizontal, vertical, or in between (see Faults in a Nutshell).
They occur in different geologic settings, deep within continents or out in the ocean.
Yet somehow, we want a single meaningful number for ranking the world's earthquakes.
The goal has always been to figure out the total amount of energy a quake releases, because that tells us profound things about the dynamics of the Earth's interior.
Richter's First Scale
The pioneering seismologist Charles Richter started in the 1930s by simplifying everything he could think of.
He chose one standard instrument, a Wood-Anderson seismograph, used only nearby earthquakes in Southern California, and took only one piece of data — the distance A in millimeters that the seismograph needle moved.
He worked up a simple adjustment factor B to allow for near versus distant quakes, and that was the first Richter scale of local magnitude ML:
ML = log A + B
A graphical version of his scale is reproduced on the Caltech archives site.
You'll notice that ML really measures the size of earthquake waves, not an earthquake's total energy, but it was a start.
This scale worked fairly well as far as it went, which was for small and moderate earthquakes in Southern California.
Over the next 20 years Richter and many other workers extended the scale to newer seismometers, different regions, and different kinds of seismic waves.
Later "Richter Scales"
Soon enough Richter's original scale was abandoned, but the public and the press still use the phrase "Richter magnitude."
Seismologists used to mind, but not anymore.
Today seismic events may be measured based on body waves or surface waves (these are explained in Earthquakes in a Nutshell).
The formulas differ but they yield the same numbers for moderate earthquakes.
Body-wave magnitude is
mb = log(A/T) + Q(D,h)
where A is the ground motion (in microns), T is the wave's period (in seconds), and Q(D,h) is a correction factor that depends on distance to the quake's epicenter D (in degrees) and focal depth h (in kilometers).
Surface-wave magnitude is
Ms = log(A/T) + 1.66 logD + 3.30
mb uses relatively short seismic waves with a 1-second period, so to it every quake source that is larger than a few wavelengths looks the same.
That corresponds to a magnitude of about 6.5. Ms uses 20-second waves and can handle larger sources, but it too saturates around magnitude 8.
That's OK for most purposes because magnitude-8 or great events happen only about once a year on average for the whole planet.
But within their limits, these two scales are a reliable gauge of the actual energy that earthquakes release.
The biggest earthquake whose magnitude we know was in 1960, in the Pacific right off central Chile on May 22.
Back then, it was said to be magnitude 8.5, but today we say it was 9.5.
What happened in the meantime was that Tom Hanks and Hiroo Kanamori came up with a better magnitude scale in 1979.
This moment magnitude, Mw, is not based on seismometer readings at all but on the total energy released in a quake, the seismic moment Mo (in dyne-centimeters):
Mw = 2/3 log(Mo) - 10.7
This scale therefore does not saturate. Moment magnitude can match anything the Earth can throw at us.
The formula for Mw is such that below magnitude 8 it matches Ms and below magnitude 6 it matches mb, which is close enough to Richter's old ML.
So, keep calling it the Richter scale if you like — it's the scale Richter would have made if he could.
The U.S. Geological Survey's Henry Spall interviewed Charles Richter in 1980 about "his" scale. It makes lively reading.
PS: Earthquakes on Earth simply can't get bigger than around Mw = 9.5.
A piece of rock can store up only so much strain energy before it ruptures, so the size of a quake depends strictly on how much rock — how many kilometers of fault length — can rupture at once.
The Chile Trench, where the 1960 quake occurred, is the longest straight fault in the world. The only way to get more energy is with giant landslides or asteroid impacts.

Andrew Alden
Geology Expert
Education
B.A., Earth Sciences, University of New Hampshire
Introduction
Professional geologist, writer, photographer, and geological tour guide
Thirty-seven years of experience writing about geological subjects
Six years as a research guide with U.S. Geological Survey (USGS)
Experience
Andrew Alden is a former writer for ThoughtCo who contributed hundreds of articles for more than 17 years. Andrew works as a geologist, writer, editor, and photographer. He has written on geological subjects since 1981 and participates actively in his field. For example, Andrew spent six years as a research guide with the U.S. Geological Survey, leading excursions on both land land and at sea. And since 1992, he has hosted the earthquakes conference for the online discussion platform, The Well, which began as a dialogue between the writers and readers of the Whole Earth Review. 
In addition, Andrew is a longtime member of the member of the Geological Society of America — an international society that serves members in academia, government, and industry; and the American Geophysical Union — a community of earth and space scientists that advances the power of science to ensure a sustainable future.
Andrew lives in Oakland, California; and though he writes about the whole planet and beyond, Andrew finds his own city full of interest too and blogs about its geology. 
Education
Andrew Alden holds a bachelor's (B.A.) degree in Earth Science from the University of New Hampshire, College of Engineering and Physical Sciences, in Durham, N.H.
Awards and Publications
Andrew Alden on Earthquakes ​(The Well Group, Inc., 2011)
Assessment of River — Floodplain Aquifer Interactions (Environmental and Engineering Geoscience, 1997)
Andrew Alden on Hosting (The Well Group, Inc., 1995)
ThoughtCo and Dotdash
ThoughtCo is a premier reference site focusing on expert-created education content. We are one of the top-10 information sites in the world as rated by comScore, a leading Internet measurement company. Every month, more than 13 million readers seek answers to their questions on ThoughtCo.
For more than 20 years, Dotdash brands have been helping people find answers, solve problems, and get inspired. We are one of the top-20 largest content publishers on the Internet according to comScore, and reach more than 30% of the U.S. population monthly. Our brands collectively have won more than 20 industry awards in the last year alone, and recently Dotdash was named Publisher of the Year by Digiday, a leading industry publication.
Visible earthquake damage.

Saturday, June 29, 2019

EARTHQUAKE AFTERSHOCKS - The definition that scientists use for an aftershock is any seismic event occurring within one rupture-zone length of a main shock and within the time it takes for seismicity to fall off to what it was before the main shock. Aftershocks aren't restricted to the spot where the main shock occurred, but can strike tens of kilometers away. Aftershocks don't necessarily get smaller as time passes. They get fewer, but sizable ones can happen long after most of the little ones have ended. Aftershocks are good ways to map the underground fault zone that ruptured in the main shock. Aftershocks are also interesting because they're fairly well behaved — meaning that they have a detectable pattern, unlike all other quakes.

Image result for images Aftershocks Are Not Afterthoughts
...........................................................................................................................................
Earthquake Aftershocks
Aftershocks Are Not Afterthoughts
by Andrew Alden


Aftershocks, those who live through major earthquakes often say, are worse than the main shock in their own way.
At least the main shock took them by surprise and was over fairly soon, in less than a minute usually.
But with aftershocks, people are stressed already, dealing with disrupted lives and cities. They expect aftershocks at any minute, day or night.
When a building is damaged by the main shock, aftershocks can take it down — maybe when you're inside cleaning it up.
No wonder Susan Hough, the government seismologist who gets in the news whenever temblors do, calls aftershocks "ghosts of earthquakes past."
The Duration of Aftershocks
I can show you some aftershocks right now: just look at the map of recent earthquakes for the San Simeon area of California.
In any given week, there are aftershocks there from the 2003 San Simeon earthquake.
And east of Barstow you can still see a trickle of aftershocks from the October 1999 Hector Mine earthquake.
Indeed, some scientists argue that aftershocks may last for centuries in places, like continental interiors, where plate motions that build up stresses in the crust are very slow.
This makes intuitive sense, but careful studies using long historical catalogs will need to be done.
The Trouble with Aftershocks
Two things about aftershocks make them troublesome.
First, they aren't restricted to the spot where the main shock occurred, but can strike tens of kilometers away — and, say, if a magnitude 7 quake was centered out beyond the suburbs but one of its magnitude 5 aftershocks happened right underneath City Hall, the littler one might be the worse of the two.
This was the case with the Christchurch, New Zealand earthquake of September 2010 and its large aftershock five months later.
Second, aftershocks don't necessarily get smaller as time passes. They get fewer, but sizable ones can happen long after most of the little ones have ended.
In Southern California, this phenomenon aroused so much concern after the Northridge quake of 17 January 1994 that Hough wrote an op-ed piece for the Los Angeles Times on the subject three full years later.
Scientific Uses of Aftershocks
Aftershocks are scientifically interesting because they are good ways to map the underground fault zone that ruptured in the main shock. (Here's how they look for the cases of Northridge.)
In the case of the 28 September 2004 Parkfield quake, you can see that the first hour of aftershocks alone outlines the ruptured zone quite well.
Aftershocks are also interesting because they're fairly well behaved — meaning that they have a detectable pattern, unlike all other quakes.
The definition that scientists use for an aftershock is any seismic event occurring within one rupture-zone length of a main shock and within the time it takes for seismicity to fall off to what it was before the main shock.
This body of quakes fits three mathematical rules, more or less.
The first is the Gutenberg-Richter relation, which says that as you go down one magnitude unit in size, aftershocks increase in number by about ten times.
The second is called Bath's law, which says that the largest aftershock is, on average, 1.2 magnitude units smaller than the main shock.
And finally, Omori's law states that aftershock frequency decreases by roughly the reciprocal of time after the main shock.
These numbers differ a bit in different active regions depending on their geology, but they're close enough for government work as the saying goes.
So, seismologists can advise the authorities immediately after a large earthquake that a certain area can expect X probabilities of aftershocks of Y sizes for Z period of time.
The U.S. Geological Survey's STEP project produces a daily map of California with the current risk of strong aftershocks for the next 24 hours.
That's as good a forecast as we can make, and probably the best possible given that earthquakes are inherently unpredictable.
Aftershocks in the Quiet Zones
Still to be determined is how much Omori's law varies beyond active tectonic settings. Large earthquakes are rare away from plate boundary zones, but a 2000 paper in Seismological Research Letters by John Ebel showed that aftershocks of these intra-plate earthquakes could last for several centuries.
One of those was the 1663 Charlevoix, Quebec, earthquake; another was the 1356 earthquake in Basel, Switzerland. In the American Midwest, those would be prehistoric events.
In 2009 Seth Stein and Mian Liu argued in Nature that these quiet settings seem to slow everything down, with stress increasing slowly and aftershock sequences lasting longer.
They also noted that where the historical record is short, such as in the United States, it may be a mistake to judge the degree of earthquake hazard from events that are actually aftershocks rather than background seismicity.
This knowledge may not help you cope with your nerves if you live in an aftershock zone. But it does give you some guidelines as to how bad things will be.
And more concretely, it can help engineers judge how probable it is that your new building will be hit by significant aftershocks over the next few years and plan accordingly.
PS: Susan Hough and her colleague Lucy Jones wrote an article on this subject for Eos, the house journal for the American Geophysical Union, in November 1997.
The U.S. Geological Survey scientists closed by saying that "we would like to propose that the phrase 'just an aftershock' be hereafter banned from the English language."
Tell your neighbors.

Andrew Alden
Professional geologist, writer, photographer, and geological tour guide
Thirty-seven years of experience writing about geological subjects
Six years as a research guide with U.S. Geological Survey (USGS)
Experience
Andrew Alden is a former writer for ThoughtCo who contributed hundreds of articles for more than 17 years. Andrew works as a geologist, writer, editor, and photographer. He has written on geological subjects since 1981 and participates actively in his field. For example, Andrew spent six years as a research guide with the U.S. Geological Survey, leading excursions on both land land and at sea. And since 1992, he has hosted the earthquakes conference for the online discussion platform, The Well, which began as a dialogue between the writers and readers of the Whole Earth Review. 
In addition, Andrew is a longtime member of the member of the Geological Society of America — an international society that serves members in academia, government, and industry; and the American Geophysical Union — a community of earth and space scientists that advances the power of science to ensure a sustainable future.
Andrew lives in Oakland, California; and though he writes about the whole planet and beyond, Andrew finds his own city full of interest too and blogs about its geology. 
Education
Andrew Alden holds a bachelor's (B.A.) degree in Earth Science from the University of New Hampshire, College of Engineering and Physical Sciences, in Durham, N.H.
Awards and Publications
Andrew Alden on Earthquakes ​(The Well Group, Inc., 2011)
Assessment of River — Floodplain Aquifer Interactions (Environmental and Engineering Geoscience, 1997)
Andrew Alden on Hosting (The Well Group, Inc., 1995)
ThoughtCo and Dotdash
ThoughtCo is a premier reference site focusing on expert-created education content. We are one of the top-10 information sites in the world as rated by comScore, a leading Internet measurement company. Every month, more than 13 million readers seek answers to their questions on ThoughtCo.
For more than 20 years, Dotdash brands have been helping people find answers, solve problems, and get inspired. We are one of the top-20 largest content publishers on the Internet according to comScore, and reach more than 30% of the U.S. population monthly. Our brands collectively have won more than 20 industry awards in the last year alone, and recently Dotdash was named Publisher of the Year by Digiday, a leading industry publication.

Image result for images Aftershocks Are Not Afterthoughts