SPONTANEOUS GENERATION - Spontaneous generation is the idea that living organisms can spontaneously come from nonliving matter. Over the years, great minds like Aristotle and Isaac Newton were proponents of some aspects of spontaneous generation which have all been shown to be false. Prior to the mid-19th century, it was commonly believed that the origin of certain animals was from nonliving sources. Lice were thought to come from dirt or sweat. Worms, salamanders, and frogs were thought to be birthed from the mud. Maggots were derived from rotting meat, aphids and beetles supposedly sprang from wheat, and mice were generated from soiled clothing mixed with wheat grains. While these theories seem quite ludicrous, at the time they were thought to be reasonable explanations for how certain bugs and other animals seemed to appear from no other living matter. While a popular theory throughout history, spontaneous generation was not without its critics. Several scientists set out to refute this theory through scientific experimentation. At the same time, other scientists tried to find evidence in support of spontaneous generation. This debate would last for centuries.

.................................................................................................................................................................

Spontaneous Generation

Is Spontaneous Generation Real?

By Regina Bailey

For several centuries it was believed that living organisms could spontaneously come from nonliving matter.

This idea, known as spontaneous generation, is now known to be false.

Proponents of at least some aspects of spontaneous generation included well-respected philosophers and scientists such as Aristotle, Rene Descartes, William Harvey, and Isaac Newton.

Spontaneous generation was a popular notion due to the fact that it seemed to be consistent with observations that a number of animal organisms would apparently arise from nonliving sources.

Spontaneous generation was disproved through the performance of several significant scientific experiments.

Key Takeaways

·      Spontaneous generation is the idea that living organisms can spontaneously come from nonliving matter.

·      Over the years, great minds like Aristotle and Isaac Newton were proponents of some aspects of spontaneous generation which have all been shown to be false.

·      Francesco Redi did an experiment with meat and maggots and concluded that maggots do not arise spontaneously from rotting meat.

·      The Needham and the Spallanzani experiments were additional experiments that were conducted to help disprove spontaneous generation.

·      The Pasteur experiment was the most famous experiment conducted that disproved spontaneous generation that was accepted by the majority of the scientific community. Pasteur demonstrated that bacteria appearing in broth are not the result of spontaneous generation.

Do Animals Spontaneously Generate?

Prior to the mid-19th century, it was commonly believed that the origin of certain animals was from nonliving sources.

Lice were thought to come from dirt or sweat.

Worms, salamanders, and frogs were thought to be birthed from the mud.

Maggots were derived from rotting meat, aphids and beetles supposedly sprang from wheat, and mice were generated from soiled clothing mixed with wheat grains.

While these theories seem quite ludicrous, at the time they were thought to be reasonable explanations for how certain bugs and other animals seemed to appear from no other living matter.

Spontaneous Generation Debate

While a popular theory throughout history, spontaneous generation was not without its critics.

Several scientists set out to refute this theory through scientific experimentation.

At the same time, other scientists tried to find evidence in support of spontaneous generation. This debate would last for centuries.

Redi Experiment

In 1668, the Italian scientist and physician Francesco Redi set out to disprove the hypothesis that maggots were spontaneously generated from rotting meat.

He contended that the maggots were the result of flies laying eggs on exposed meat.

In his experiment, Redi placed meat in several jars. Some jars were left uncovered, some were covered with gauze, and some were sealed with a lid.

Over time, the meat in the uncovered jars and the jars covered with gauze became infested with maggots.

However, the meat in the sealed jars did not have maggots.

Since only the meat that was accessible to flies had maggots, Redi concluded that maggots do not spontaneously arise from meat.

Needham Experiment

In 1745, English biologist and priest John Needham set out to demonstrate that microbes, such as bacteria, were the result of spontaneous generation.

Thanks to the invention of the microscope in the 1600s and increased improvements to its usage, scientists were able to view microscopic organisms such as fungi, bacteria, and protists.

In his experiment, Needham heated chicken broth in a flask in order to kill any living organisms within the broth. He allowed the broth to cool and placed it in a sealed flask.

Needham also placed unheated broth in another container. Over time, both the heated broth and unheated broth contained microbes.

Needham was convinced that his experiment had proven spontaneous generation in microbes.

Spallanzani Experiment

In 1765, Italian biologist and priest Lazzaro Spallanzani, set out to demonstrate that microbes do not spontaneously generate.

He contended that microbes are capable of moving through the air.

Spallanzani believed that microbes appeared in Needham's experiment because the broth had been exposed to air after boiling but before the flask had been sealed.

Spallanzani devised an experiment where he placed the broth in a flask, sealed the flask, and removed the air from the flask before boiling.

The results of his experiment showed that no microbes appeared in the broth as long as it remained in its sealed condition.

While it appeared that the results of this experiment had dealt a devastating blow to the idea of spontaneous generation in microbes,

Needham argued that it was the removal of air from the flask that made spontaneous generation impossible.

Pasteur Experiment

In 1861, Louis Pasteur presented evidence that would virtually put an end to the debate.

He designed an experiment similar to Spallanzani's, however, Pasteur's experiment implemented a way to filter out microorganisms.

Pasteur used a flask with a long, curved tube called a swan-necked flask. This flask allowed air to have access to the heated broth while trapping dust containing bacterial spores in the curved neck of the tube.

The results of this experiment were that no microbes grew in the broth.

When Pasteur tilted the flask on its side allowing the broth access to the curved neck of the tube and then set the flask upright again, the broth became contaminated and ​bacteria reproduced in the broth.

Bacteria also appeared in the broth if the flask was broken near the neck allowing the broth to be exposed to non-filtered air.

This experiment demonstrated that bacteria appearing in broth are not the result of spontaneous generation.

The majority of the scientific community considered this conclusive evidence against spontaneous generation and proof that living organisms only arise from living organisms.

Regina Bailey , RN

Biology Expert

Education

B.A., Biology, Emory University

A.S., Nursing, Chattahoochee Technical College

Introduction

Biology expert for ThoughtCo (formerly About Education) since 1997

Author of the forward to The Complete Idiot's Guide to Understanding Cloning

Experience

Regina is a board-certified registered nurse and owner of a content development firm specializing in the development of biology and science-related content. She has written about biology for ThoughtCo (formerly About Education) since 1997.

Regina's expertise has been featured and/or referenced in Kaplan AP Biology 2016, The Internet for Cellular and Molecular Biologists, and The Seven Disciplines of Wellness: The Spiritual Connection to Good Health.

Regina also wrote the forward to The Complete Idiot's Guide to Understanding Cloning.

Education

Regina holds a B.A. in biology from Emory University and an A.S. in Nursing from Chattahoochee Technical College. 

ThoughtCo and Dotdash

ThoughtCo is a premier reference site focusing on expert-created education content. We are one of the top-10 information sites in the world as rated by comScore, a leading Internet measurement company. Every month, more than 13 million readers seek answers to their questions on ThoughtCo.

For more than 20 years, Dotdash brands have been helping people find answers, solve problems, and get inspired. We are one of the top-20 largest content publishers on the Internet according to comScore, and reach more than 30% of the U.S. population monthly. Our brands collectively have won more than 20 industry awards in the last year alone, and recently Dotdash was named Publisher of the Year by Digiday, a leading industry publication.

https://www.thoughtco.com/spontaneous-generation-4118145