FOOL'S GOLD – Pyrite received the nickname "Fool's gold" because it is worth virtually nothing, but has an appearance that "fools" people into believing that it is gold. The nickname "fool's gold" has long been used by gold buyers and prospectors, who were amused by excited people who thought they had found gold. These people did not know how to tell the difference between pyrite and gold, and their ignorance caused them to look foolish. Chalcopyrite and small pieces of biotite mica can fool you. Chalcopyrite (a copper iron sulfide) has very similar properties to pyrite.

.............................................................................................................................................

Fool's Gold

Don't be fooled: These quick tests separate pyrite from real gold

Article by: Hobart M. King, Ph.D., RPG

What Is Fool's Gold?

"Fool's gold" is a common nickname for pyrite.

Pyrite received that nickname because it is worth virtually nothing, but has an appearance that "fools" people into believing that it is gold.

With a little practice, there are many easy tests that anyone can use to quickly tell the difference between pyrite and gold.

The nickname "fool's gold" has long been used by gold buyers and prospectors, who were amused by excited people who thought they had found gold.

These people did not know how to tell the difference between pyrite and gold, and their ignorance caused them to look foolish.

Separating Fool's Gold from Gold

Here are a few simple tests that almost anyone can use to tell the difference between pyrite and gold. They can usually be done successfully by inexperienced people.

However, wise people obtain a couple small pieces of pyrite and a couple small pieces of gold and use them to gain valuable experience.

CAUTION: All pieces of gold are valuable. However, any piece of gold with a nice crystal habit will have a premium value - often worth several times the value of its contained gold. That premium value can be ruined by some of the tests explained below. So, we have separated the tests into "destructive tests" and "non-destructive tests". Be careful if you think that you might have a valuable gold specimen.

Non-Destructive Tests

A) Tarnish: Most specimens of pyrite, found in nature, will have at least some tarnish on their surface. Nuggets or small flakes of gold are usually bright and untarnished.

B) Color: Pyrite has a brassy color. Gold has a golden to yellow color. Most native gold is alloyed with silver, and if the silver content is high enough, the specimen will have a whitish yellow color.

C) Shape: Pyrite is usually found as angular pieces, and many of them exhibit the faces of a cube, octahedron or pyritohedron. Most gold particles found in streams have slightly rounded edges, but be careful - some crystalline gold specimens can display a crystal habit that is similar to pyrite.

D) Striations: Many crystals of pyrite have fine parallel lines on their faces. Gold crystals do not have striations.

E) Specific Gravity: Gold has a specific gravity of about 19.3. The specific gravity of pyrite is about 5. (All gold found in nature is always alloyed with other metals. These metals have a specific gravity which will reduce the specific gravity of the specimen, but never enough that it approaches the specific gravity of pyrite. Specimens containing a significant amount of gold will always have at least two to three times the specific gravity of pyrite.)

Destructive Tests

A) Streak: Gold has a yellow streak. Pyrite has a greenish black streak. Learn how to do the streak test here.

B) Hardness: Gold has a Mohs hardness of 2.5, while pyrite has a Mohs hardness of 6 to 6.5. Gold will not scratch a copper surface (Mohs hardness of 3), but pyrite will easily scratch copper. Gold can be scratched by a sharp piece of copper, but copper will scratch very few other materials. Learn about the Mohs hardness test here.

C) Ductility: Gold is very ductile, and a tiny piece of gold will bend or dent with pressure from a pin or a pointed piece of wood. Tiny pieces of pyrite will break or resist the pressure.

D) Sectility: Small particles of gold can be cut with a sharp pocket knife. Small particles of pyrite cannot be cut.

Other Minerals That Can Fool You!

Chalcopyrite and small pieces of biotite mica can fool you. Chalcopyrite (a copper iron sulfide) has very similar properties to pyrite.

It has a lower hardness than pyrite (3.5 to 4) and a lower specific gravity than pyrite (4.1 to 4.3), but the same tests can separate chalcopyrite from gold. Chalcopyrite also has a greenish black streak.

Many people are surprised that biotite mica can fool people into thinking that it is gold. This most often occurs when an inexperienced person is panning for gold and sees a bright flash in their gold pan.

After chasing the tiny, highly lustrous flake, they think that it might be gold. However, slight pressure with a pin can break the flake of mica, but a tiny flake of gold will bend around the pin.

Hobart M. King is the owner and publisher of Geology.com. He is a geologist with over 40 years of experience, has a Ph.D. in geology, and is a GIA graduate gemologist. Much of his work has focused on coal geology, industrial minerals, gemology, geologic hazards, and geoscience education.

He has authored many of the internet’s most popular articles about rocks, minerals and gems. He writes most of the content published on Geology.com and compiles its daily news. His writing is read by over a million people each month, making him one of the world’s most widely read geologists.

Dr. King earned a Ph.D. and an M.S. in geology from West Virginia University; a B.S. in geology from California University of Pennsylvania; and, a Graduate Gemologist Diploma from the Gemological Institute of America. He is a registered professional geologist in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

He has worked as a geologist in a variety of settings since 1975.

https://geology.com/gold/fools-gold/

Chalcopyrite in Dolomite and Quartz: Gold-colored minerals can be tested even if they are embedded in a rock. The gold-colored mineral in this rock is chalcopyrite, and a person could determine that it is not gold by poking the gold-colored material with a pin and observing if it dents or breaks. This photograph is by Scott Horvath of the United States Geological Survey. 

Gold's Streak: A copper penny and a tiny gold nugget on a black streak plate, with a small streak made by the nugget. The copper penny is in the photo to serve as a scale. The tiny nugget weighs 0.0035 troy ounce, and at a gold price of $1200/ozt the nugget, if it were pure gold, would have a gold value of $4.20. The tiny mark left by the streak plate removed about $0.06 worth of gold from the nugget.

Testing Specific Gravity: Specific Gravity is the ratio between the weight of a material in air and the weight of an equal volume of water. The device in the photo above is a scale that is used to weigh the material in air, and a weighing pan that enables the material to be weighed under water. The weight under water can be subtracted from the weight in air to obtain the weight of the volume of water displaced by the material. Specific gravity is then calculated by the formula: Wa / (Wa - Wu) where Wa is the weight of the material in air and Wu is the weight of the material under water.

Crystalline Gold: A specimen of native gold from Pontes e Lacerda, Mato Grosso, Brazil, approximately 3.5 centimeters tall. This specimen is visually appealing and displays the crystalline habit of gold. The value of this specimen to collectors of crystalline gold would be many times the value of its contained gold. Destructive tests should not be done on specimens of gold that display a crystalline habit or specimens of no trivial size that have an attractive appearance. 

Pyrite with Striations: A cluster of cubic pyrite crystals exhibiting prominent striations.